Chainshade (Marc) Apply.

Smithers, we know your opinion.

He in fact has been in gfm on numerous occasions but most of you have been afk when he was there.

BunnyLein wrote:

smithers wrote:Thread closed

stop inpersonating yura

^ +1 I guess the choice of closing and opening threads is still up to me


I know this topic has been open for long enough and I still do not see any clear satisfaction from our guild members' side for which I do not feel ready to give a yes yet.
Also, it is actually bugging me that he does not only have a No by some of our members and ex members, but a seriously bad image by them. We still prefer our current guild members over new applicants. It's mentioned in the rules and applies to every single member unless they are ready to give a second chance.

Bad image is from Joe's post right? I can get why Joe is pissed and all but I do think Marc deserves a second chance from Joe.

Besides that Wessel and Smithers have gives a no. Wessel because of his lack of funding and smithers just felt "bad aura" from him.

I do get what Wessel pointed out and that's the reason I haven't given a yes yet. However I don't quite get the hostility from Smithers, there seems to be no clear reason why he's so against Marc.

Well he said he wouldnt mind joining the Jr guild, if I remember correct, in that case he gets a yes from me for JrGuild to try a trial period.
But for main guild I'm not gonna vote a yes. because I feel like Smit hates him. xD

Umm in my opinion we should give Marc a trial period and see how he gets on.

Btw hey Marc I would like to see u at GFM sometimes my in-game character name is LegacyDodge I never seen at GFM at all maybe I was afk orso, You can add me in buddy so I can have a chat with you. HOPE TO SEE YOU SOON.

I'll vote no on this also.

This apps been open for too long, no one really has anything positive to say. I haven't heard from Marc since he started the app. Don't want someone here just because of a sympathy vote because the app was open for a while for and to end up having him here with people not really knowing him properly. If he couldn't get to know people during his app phase i.e when he should be getting to know people, I think he'd just fade into the background.

Also I don't particularly see what he would add to the guild and with his knowledge/attitude as it is it'll be a long time before he can.

i kinda think the same as alex and i also found almost no people who know you or something what makes me think how you make your mesos and such

and i also see no try from you to get into the guild beside afking in gfm . i never had a chat with you in this time

sooo i'm going for a no aswell

Hey everybody, sorry if i didnt improve much, neither been much in gfm to get to know ppl i havent been able to play alot lately had alot of homework en prep stuff for exams also was finding a job so had solicitations daily.

Ill get online more from now on my shad ill be in gfm and feel free to pm me

I guess this application was open for long enough and I'm sorry but I guess I gotta give a No on this.

Nevertheless, wish you happy mapling

Locked.